I felt like I was trapped in one of those terrifying nightmares, the one where you have to run, run till your lungs burst, but you can’t make your body move fast enough. My legs seemed to move slower and slower as I fought my way through the callous crowd, but the hands on the huge clock tower didn’t slow. With relentless, uncaring force, they turned inexorably toward the end–the end of everything.
Lady, I hear ya.
It’s almost been a year since the events of the first book and Bella Swan’s birthday has come round. Turning eighteen only serves to remind her that she is growing older, while her vampire boyfriend Edward remains seventeen. And a high school senior! So things are already not proceeding that smoothly for the ‘teenage’ couple when they decide to celebrate Bella’s birthday at the Cullen family household. Then Edward’s adopted brother Jasper is sent into a frenzy at the sight of Bella’s blood caused by a small papercut. As this confirms the worst fears of Bella’s vampire swain, he decides to leave her and the town of Forks, taking his family with him to some unknown destination.
Abandoned by Edward, Bella falls into a deep depression, only surfacing when she reacquaints herself with Jacob Black, who still nurses a crush on her. She enjoys his company and so tries to insist that their relationship is simply a friendship. Jacob proves to be extremely persistent, taking her gentle refusals with good humour and puppy-dog eyes. Still she cannot forget her passionate obsession for Edward Cullen and even begins to experience hallucinations of his presence when her life is in danger. Eventually Jacob’s warmth and affection slowly wears away her resolve and she starts to think of a life without Edward. Until one day he simply cuts off all contact. Feeling lost and bewildered she wanders into the forests surrounding Forks, only to meet Laurent, a member of the vampire pack that had hunted her the previous year. He brings her a message from Victoria. They’re going to kill her and with the Cullens gone, there is no one to protect her. Bella’s fate seems sealed, but then a pack of werewolves arrive to defend her. One of them even looks familiar to her. Are there any boys in Forks that are not mythical monsters!
Are we sitting comfortably? Then let’s begin. Perhaps my description of the plot implies that this is an exciting tale of danger. Well, it’s not. Not be a long shot. There are upswings of excitement in the narrative, but they come few and far between. I hate all the male characters. I am sick of the endless descriptions of Edward’s perfection and in this book Jacob’s muscular frame also heaves into view. The only other things Meyer seems interested in are cars! There’s a major disjunct in the story after the Cullens leave, with the plot of the first book seeming to repeat itself when Bella discovers yet another clan of fantasy creatures living nearby. As for the main character, I dislike how what little description of Bella we get show her to be a clumsy clod, a ‘magnet for danger’ and completely unable to cope without a man in her life. The religious subtext of the books also bothers me. Worst of all, Bella’s rejection by Edward leaves her an automaton, focused on being a ‘good girl’ for her dad, cooking, cleaning and keeping her grades up. She never feels any anger towards the vampire, which usually helps when you’ve had your heart broken.
On the other hand… I don’t like these books, but lots of folks do, so who am I to throw the first stone? After all I just reviewed Brandon Sanderson purely to get a bead on how he would finish up the Wheel of Time series and they are terrible books. Maybe the kids reading Twilight will grow out of them and find Jodi Piccoult. Or if they’re fans of the beefcake, maybe they’ll discover Anais Nin? Also if the Volturi are a dig at the Church of Rome, well I’m not too bothered by that. Hell it reminded me of a Bill Hicks quote. So I guess live and let live is my conclusion. I’m tired of all the obnoxious complaining about Twifans, as it only led to this.
Furthermore…Team Alice? Oh Meyer, you cad!




6 comments
Comments feed for this article
August 27, 2010 at 7:26 pm
Jonathan
Emmet, just be thankful you didn’t actually watch any of the movies.
http://spacetweek.livejournal.com/116623.html
August 28, 2010 at 1:06 pm
wordofmousebooks
Emmet, you made it through!HA! Good on you!
Interestingly while you found the lengthy descriptions of musclar frames and Edward’s perfection annoying, I didn’t mind them, then again I do have a 15-yr-old female self, somewhere deep down inside to tap into!
Yes, they are all rather vapid characters epecially Bella (I guess the thought is that Bella is so plain and hardy mentioned that the teenage reader can just insert herself into the story) and just so you know Bella’s breakdown after Edward’s departure was FAR more annoying in the movie, Jonathan makes a great point (although I liked those too -perhaps it was the visual representation of Edward’s perfection and Jabob’s muscular frame that won me over!)
At least you can say you tried it!
Cheers
Stacey
August 28, 2010 at 4:40 pm
Emmet
Hey Stacey, thanks again for the comment. Would you believe it, the original piece ran over 900 words. I cut back a lot of material about Charlie Swan and Meyer’s characterisation to keep within my limit.
What I find interesting about the books is that usually a writer describing the thoughts and feelings of a teenager in fiction brings their life experience since into play. The aim is to capture the poignancy of being young, but at the same time reflect on what it all means.
With Meyer, I don’t see that. It’s almost as if there is no reflection on her part as to what it means to be a teen. Instead, I feel as if she is reliving those years through an idealised fictional prism.
So in a way I can see how the books are so popular to readers of all ages. I do resent it as Twilight is the ‘anti-Buffy’, in many ways. Whedon’s television series had all the same tropes – the emtional drama of being a teenager mixed with fantasy creatures – but Meyer is writing pure fantasy and escapism. Buffy was about a girl fighting to define herself. Bella lands a rich, beautiful boy with whom she can remain young forever.
August 28, 2010 at 4:31 pm
blurredlights
somewhere along the way, i wanted to chuck this book out. but i kept thinking it might get better, and found that it only got worse.
are you planning on reading eclipse as well? if so, then i wish you luck.
August 28, 2010 at 4:42 pm
Emmet
@blurredlights – cheers, I try to avoid rereading authors for the blog. If I didn’t this blog would just feature reviews of one Philip K. Dick book after another!
December 27, 2011 at 12:15 pm
The Drowning City by Amanda Downum « …. i can stay
[...] by a woman. Perhaps that strikes you as a strange prerequisite, but to my mind the success of Twilight and its ilk proves that there is a huge demand for fantasy literature among women, but the [...]